PJM Auction Delay Sought by 8 Consumer Advocates Over $5-10B Cost
Eight state consumer-advocate offices asked PJM's board on Nov. 18 to seek FERC approval to postpone the Dec. 9-15 capacity auction; the market monitor puts the data-center cost at $5-10 billion.
3 min read
Follows PJM Monitor: Data Centers Added $9.95/MWh; 9-Month Cost Hits $70.81B

The PJM control room, from an earlier PJM Inside Lines photo; it is not an image of the auction.
Image: PJM Interconnection
Source · Press image from the PJM Interconnection Inside Lines site, used for news reporting.
Eight state consumer-advocate offices asked the PJM Interconnection board in a Nov. 18 letter to seek federal approval to postpone the Dec. 9-15 capacity auction for the 2029/2030 delivery year, citing the market monitor's estimate that it could add $5 billion to $10 billion in data-center costs.
The signatories are the Ohio Consumers' Counsel, the Delaware Public Advocate, the West Virginia Consumer Advocate, Maryland's Office of People's Counsel, the Pennsylvania Office of Consumer Advocate, the New Jersey Division of Rate Counsel, the Illinois Attorney General's Office and the Illinois Citizens Utility Board. Their letter asks the board to direct PJM to seek authorization from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) to hold off until data-center load, "both real and speculative," is removed from the load forecast and a separate reliability backstop procurement for large loads proceeds. They want a written answer by Nov. 23, according to the letter and to Utility Dive, which reported it on Nov. 19.
The advocates ask for a PJM Board reply by Nov. 23, ahead of the Dec. 9-15 auction.
Graphic: Voltgrid News
What the Monitor Said First
The request builds on the market monitor's Nov. 12 report. Voltgrid covered it when PJM's market monitor put data-center capacity costs at $29.4 billion. In that third-quarter State of the Market report, Monitoring Analytics said the 2029/2030 auction will use a forecast that includes data centers it considers canceled or unlikely to reach projected demand, and that this would clear the auction at the maximum price and add another $5 billion to $10 billion for all customers. It recommended postponing the auction.
The advocates stress that the monitor does not simply want a refreshed forecast. In their words, it wants to change how forecast data-center demand is treated so existing consumers do not subsidize uncommitted load. They note that PJM was due to publish final planning parameters for the auction on Nov. 19, and say even a forecast with canceled projects removed would not meet that recommendation.
PJM's Answer and the Price Cap
PJM spokesman Jeffrey Shields told Utility Dive that the December auction has an established price cap that safeguards against high prices, and that postponing it this close to the auction "could destabilize the market and increase the risk of power interruptions." PJM's planning-parameters report sets the cap at $337.83/MW-day and a floor of $181.91/MW-day for 2029/2030, and puts forecast peak load at 171,916 MW.
The advocates argue the delay would not disturb that cap, because FERC's order extending it set no condition on the auction date. Maryland People's Counsel David Lapp told the Daily Caller News Foundation that an on-schedule auction would clear at the same cap as earlier ones, so bills would not rise above earlier years, but would keep data-center costs of more than $10 a month, "and possibly much higher," in rates. Both the Ohio and Maryland offices said they are weighing action at FERC if the board declines.
Opposition and the Exelon Link
The Electric Power Supply Association, which represents competitive generators, said late rule changes and delays add risk that ultimately raises costs, and a Manhattan Institute researcher said a debate over charging data centers should not delay an imminent auction, the Daily Caller reported.
The letter also points to Exelon's FERC complaint in docket EL27-11, which asked for a prompt auction two months before delivery when it was filed on Nov. 3. The advocates note that Exelon's requested relief would begin with the 2030/2031 delivery year, so it would not change the December auction. Separately, PJM has proposed to halve data-center study times to one year.
What is not confirmed yet
PJM's board has not said whether it will respond by Nov. 23 or seek a delay, and Utility Dive notes PJM would need FERC approval to move the auction. The $5 billion to $10 billion figure is the monitor's estimate, not a result, and the $29.4 billion is a cumulative figure for earlier auctions. We did not find the planning parameters PJM was due to publish on Nov. 19, so whether they trim data-center load is unknown.
Sources
- 012026 Quarterly State of the Market Report for PJM: January through SeptemberMonitoring Analytics (PJM Independent Market Monitor)monitoringanalytics.com
- 02Consumer Watchdogs From Ohio To Illinois Want Grid Auction Delayed Over Data Center CostsDaily Caller News Foundationdailycaller.com
- 03PJM urged to delay base capacity auction until data centers cut from forecastUtility Diveutilitydive.com
- 04Urgent request to postpone the 2029/2030 delivery year capacity auction: letter to PJM BoardState consumer advocates (letter to PJM Board)s3.documentcloud.org
- 052029/2030 Planning Period Parameters for the Base Residual AuctionPJMpjm.com
- Published
- Sources
- 5 cited





